Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

:blowkiss:
 
About Me Member Deviously Deviant Marcus Pavani16/Male/Brazil Recent Activity Deviant for 6 Months
Needs Premium Membership
Statistics 83 Deviations
645 Comments
1,299 Pageviews

deviantID

Devious Info

  • Current Residence: Barra Bonita
  • Favourite movie: The Lord of the Rings
  • Favourite band or musician: Kiss
  • Favourite genre of music: Metal
  • Favourite photographer: m-clars
  • Operating System: Windows Vista Ultimate Home Edition
  • MP3 player of choice: iTunes
  • Favourite game: Guitar Hero
  • Favourite gaming platform: PS3

My HBP critique

Fri Jul 24, 2009, 1:57 PM
Okay people.. let me talk a little...

First of all, the movie is great! The visual effects, the image itself, the sound, everything is perfect!
But c'mon, they screwed up the book! Sorry to say, but I didn't like this!
I mean, they could have followed the book a little more seriously!

These are some points I noticed:

- Even being Dumbledore himself, he could never have apparated from within hogwarts.
- And by the way, what happened to the apparition classes?
- Where is the couple Fleur and Bill? They didn't even appear!
- What was that that happened in The Burrow? It caught on fire! I didn't get the meaning of that!
- Dumbledore's never drunk the water Harry was trying to give him from the lake, so how would he get up like that and save him?
- It was Harry who took the locket when they were at the lake, so how come he find it near Dumbledore's dead body?
- How could Dumbledore have Riddle's diary if Harry gave it back to Malfoy? (And thats how he freed Dobby)
- What happened to Quidditch cup? Did Gryffindor win? Was Ginny the Seeker?
- Was Harry really captain of the team? That was not even mentioned!
- Did they really take those O.W.L. tests in the year before?
- What happened to Snape? No detentions to Harry?
- And last: When Harry takes his sip of Felix Felicis, he becomes lucky, NOT drunk! He started making fun of Hagrid! (Ok, I laughed at this part, but c'mon, it's a funeral!)

Sorry guys.. but that's what I think.
I know there is no way of possibly show everything that is in the book in the movie, but I think they could have done a better job.. maybe.

  • Mood: Angsty
  • Reading: Starting "Eldest"

deviantART Community Board

[x]

Friends

:icondidier13: :iconniwaj: :iconessence-blood: :iconmorbidthegrim: :iconadao001: :iconreehbr: :iconcolorful-child: :iconriffo: :icontalljohn: :icond4n747: :iconcataclysm-x: :iconhdrenesys: :iconrenesmeerocks13: :icondrnewtond: :iconcerique: :iconm-clars: :iconrdalpes: :iconneil-thompson: :iconchattenoir889:

Comments


:icondrnewtond:
:thanks: for the :+fav:. Your support of my art is greatly appreciated!!! :)

--
Talent hits a target no one else can hit; Genius hits a target no one else can see.
-Arthur Schopenhauer

Visit J.DELL Photography on the web at J.DELL Photo . COM [link]

Follow me on Twitter at @JDELLPHOTO
:iconmarcusfpavani:
No prob.. ;)

--
Why does this exist? o.O
--

Proud member of:
*HDR-Club
=PanoramaClub
=Closeup-Photography
=Black-White-Club
:icondidier13:
Vi seu DA na comu
estou te watchando...
Se puder watchar de volta, agradeço !!!

curtir muito seu trabalho parabens !
:iconmarcusfpavani:
Brigadao velho.. vou te add tambem!!

--
Why does this exist? o.O
--

Proud member of:
*HDR-Club
=PanoramaClub
=Closeup-Photography
=Black-White-Club
:iconrdalpes:
Merci

--
* * * */\ * *
* * * /. !\* *
* /\*/ .!. !\* Marc
:iconmarcusfpavani:
No prob.. ;p

--
Why does this exist? o.O
--

Proud member of:
*HDR-Club
=PanoramaClub
=Closeup-Photography
=Black-White-Club
:iconriffo:
Thank You for the fav

--
For H.
:iconmarcusfpavani:
No prob.. ;p

--
Why does this exist? o.O
--

Proud member of:
*HDR-Club
=PanoramaClub
=Closeup-Photography
=Black-White-Club
:iconmironv:
Thanks for the fav :)

--
eu sunt
:iconmarcusfpavani:
No prob.. ;p

--
Why does this exist? o.O
--

Proud member of:
*HDR-Club
=PanoramaClub
=Closeup-Photography
=Black-White-Club

Site Map